| Please sir, I want some more | | Print | |
| Written by Robert Hodge | |
| Thursday, 24 August 2006 | |
|
The role of Nancy was played by ALEXANDRIA HAMELIN, and despite having only a few hours of rehearsal, Ms. Hamelin turned in an admirable performance, appearing to be very comfortable with the role and at home with the staging. Kudos. The musical Oliver! has had a long and storied theatrical life. Lionel Bart, the show's composer, lyricist and writer, took Charles Dickens' masterpiece about a young orphan who asked for "some more" and created one of the most popular musicals of the 20th century. The performances in this production are generally average community theatre fare. However
Fagin's group is made up of some very talented young boys, who deliver great performances. Most notably, JOEL WHITE as Artful Dodger captures the essence of Dickensian England with a marvelous flair. His mastery of the choreography and the consistency of his accent and the strength of the character development make him a joy to watch. He posesses a gift for pacing that eludes many actors with far more experience and training. White is the natural leader of the boys in the gang which included GAVIN WALLACE, JOE AMBROSE, NATHANIEL BARKER, ROBERT CANTRELL, KATIE DEPP, BROOKE HENDRICKS, KAYLA JAEGER, BYRON WIGFALL and MARK WILSON. There are twenty-three local children who appear in this musical. They are divided into a group of orphans and those who are in Fagin's gang of thieves. HELEN D'ALFONSO has done a marvelous job as the Children's Vocal Coach. The kids really sang out and were remarkably on the money with the demanding song and dance numbers. Their choreography was beautifully executed and quite a few of the orphans are easily and instantly adoptable! From that chorus line of pitiful waifs, Oliver, played by DENVER CRAWFORD, emerges as the main character in an adventure that sees him endentured to a couple of local morticians, portrayed by JERRY SOWERS and LINDA MARLEY SMITH. These two have a perfect mastery of the macabre as they perform the very clever song, "That's Your Funeral." Ultimately, Oliver is delivered into the hands of Fagin, and then following his arrest as a pickpocket, lands in the custody of his grandfather. Young Crawford is charming as Oliver, and has no trouble making the audience root for him. The most impressive musical moment in the show is heard in the second act. During the number "Who Will Buy," a vocal quartet made up of EMILY SMITH as the milkmaid, WENDY NELSON as the Rose Seller, KAYLA JAEGER who is selling strawberries, and BOB SPRINGSTEAD as the Grinder, deliver a very strong blend and stops the show with their portrayals of characters which exemplify the underlying sadness of the working class of the period. With the exception of this remarkable quartet moment, this show would have benefited from a more experienced chorus. While the ensemble's sound was impressive, their blocking was unimaginiative and the acting was non-existant. The number "Consider Yourself" was cheerily sung by a mass of stoney, blank faces. In the final scene - a tense, dramatic moment - we were distracted by poorly executed improvisations. The awkwardness was exacerbated by poorly-timed staging for the leads and a general feeling that the cast wasn't quite comfortable with this section of the script. This was without a doubt the weakest section of the show. This production of Oliver!, while not as dark or brooding as previous incarnations, is still a delightful production, which is well worth seeing. It runs through August 26th. |
|
It would help if I included the link...sorry. Sammy...as for 'change the ending' are you referring to the film ending or the way Dicken's novel concluded? The ending of the PCT production was performed as written. Go to link and see for yourself. I saw the performance the same night as the reviewer. Overall, I liked the show and the performances. Is it the best show I have seen? No. But, I enjoyed the night and loved the great effort of each of the kids in the chorus. The reviewer, in my eyes, hit the review right on point. Everyone is quick to blast the reviews that contain criticism of the performances. We all strive for our best performances each time we step on the stage. If we don’t, then we do our fellow performers a disservice. The show was uneven due to the ease of some seasoned performers, such as CHRIS HULL (wow), JERRY SOWERS, and LINDA MARLEY SMITH, to give such believability to these bigger than life characters. Being seasoned myself, this is not an easy feat given this material. Unfortunately, these performances were contrasted by good and sometimes novice performances. I also saw several young performers who gave admirable efforts such as ALEXANDRIA HAMELIN as Nancy and JOEL WHITE as Artful Dodger. And yes, musically, the best ensemble moment in the show was the vocal quartet made up of EMILY SMITH as the milkmaid, WENDY NELSON as the Rose Seller, KAYLA JAEGER who is selling strawberries, and BOB SPRINGSTEAD as the Grinder. No one was mugging or stealing focus they were just giving performances to the best of their ability which is what’s expected. This, my friends, is the nature of community theatre and having a review system in place where reviewers call them like “they” see them. I wish people would stop pulling out the “this isn’t Broadway” card every time there is a negative comment made in a review. For me, who has had both good and bad reviews, it just makes the good reviews sweeter. Accept it and strive to improve whatever YOU believe to be valid criticisms for the next outing. That being said, there were some great choices made by the director in this production and some greedy ones when it comes to the set. Some of the shows best moments were encumbered by ambitious set changes. The cast, crew, and stage manager should be commended for do a great job adjusting to these choices. There were a few commendable set design mechanics though. The fold out pieces incorporated in the bridge was well thought out. I wish I could have seen more of the back drop though not sure if that was achievable given the size of the bridge. Director PETER NATALE did a good job overall. The cast and crew should definitely be commended for their effort and proud of the outcome, especially with those questionably huge scene changes. Thanks for the fun night! Once again, Peter Natale shows why he is one of the premier directors in Hampton Roads. Considering some of the comments I've read about him lately in other parts of this website, I wanted to make sure that his ability is recognized. I'm transferring soon and will miss seeing the shows put on locally here. --S/Sgt Paul Nowicki I had never seen Oliver until PCT did it and while it wasn't to me a show I would call a favorite (the ending left me with the feeling that there should have been more to the story), I did feel it was a good performance by most of the actors/actresses. I also think that just because the cast 'gives their heart and soul' doesn't mean everyone has to like it or think it was performed well. We have a right on this forum to say what we really feel about shows. Some feelings may be hurt but that is a part of theatre - not everyone has the same opinions and we may disagree, but that is how it is. As a performer on the community theatre stages myself I have had good and bad reviews and I accept them both, even if I may not agree or like what is said. That's life folks! It's easy to sit and criticize a play—never giving credit to the hours of driving to rehearsals, skipping suppers, and missing putting the children to bed, while a spouse does extra duty. Why not use this space and time instead to recognize that not having a Broadway cast and a Broadway stage, local actors and musicians gave heart and soul to their own production of Oliver. How anyone could review this play without mentioning the incredible and shimmering performance of Who Will Buy, by Emily Smith, Wendy Nelson, Kayla Jaeger, and Bob Springstead shouldn't be taken seriously. Enough with these kid's shows! Allright, they're cute, but watching them on stage is annoying. An all right show, but feel like I endured, not watched the show. Stick to adult shows, and if PCT must do kid's musicals, how about their Children's Theater venue? --Harry Very fine production. Chorus weak. Good choreography. Why did they change the ending I do not know. Mr Natale is a very able director. |






PCT's production, under the leadership of director PETER NATALE and choreographer DANA MARGULIES, has moments of brilliance, creativity, and true heart.
The night that I attended was one of those legendary nights in the
musical theatre where the female lead was unexpectedly taken ill, and
there were several changes in the casting.
this production was highlighted by CHRIS HULL's portrayal of Fagin. 